Written in light of the Employees Retraining Board reforms in the 2024 Policy Address, the government’s Report on Manpower Projection to 2028, and the 2025–26 Budget.
The issue
A shortage and a surplus at the same time. The government’s Report on Manpower Projection to 2028, published in November 2024, projects a shortfall of about 180,000 workers by 2028, with 10 of the 17 industries studied each short by more than 10,000. Unemployment is low: 3.2% (seasonally adjusted) in December 2024 to February 2025. Yet the IMF estimates that almost 40% of jobs worldwide are exposed to AI, rising to around 60% in advanced economies. Hong Kong leans heavily on finance, trade and professional services, where much of the routine clerical work is exactly what generative AI does well.
Why this turns into structural unemployment. Cyclical unemployment ends when the economy recovers. Structural unemployment doesn’t, because the jobs that come back are different from the ones that were lost. If AI cuts routine office roles while the shortages are in hands-on, person-facing work like elderly care, healthcare support, building services and construction, a displaced clerk and an unfilled care-home vacancy can sit side by side for years. The longer someone is out of work, the more their skills and confidence wear down, and the harder they are to re-employ. Economists call this hysteresis: it’s how a temporary shock becomes a permanent loss.
The system pays people to retrain after they lose their job, not before. The 2024 Policy Address accepted the recommendations to reform the Employees Retraining Board (ERB), moving it from training low-skilled workers towards skills-based training for the whole workforce. Since 1 January 2025 the ERB has dropped its education cap, opened its courses to everyone in the labour force aged 15 or above, and committed to at least 15,000 more training places in 2025–26. That’s welcome. But the ERB’s retraining allowance, up to HK$8,000 a month (HK$333 a day, or HK$166.50 a half-day), is paid for placement-tied courses aimed mainly at people who are unemployed or between jobs. A clerical worker who can see automation coming but still has a job gets no income support to retrain in the evenings. If they use the Continuing Education Fund instead, they have to pay the course fees upfront and claim the money back later. For a low-paid worker, both are real barriers.
Investment in AI has outpaced investment in the people it affects. The 2025–26 Budget earmarked HK$1 billion for a Hong Kong Artificial Intelligence Research and Development Institute. Supporting AI itself makes sense, but nothing comparable has been committed to helping workers adjust to it.
Now is the cheapest time to act. With unemployment at 3.2%, workers can retrain while they’re still employed and employers are still hiring. Waiting until displacement shows up in the unemployment figures means paying for longer spells out of work, lost tax revenue and higher welfare costs.
What we propose
1. Publish an AI Exposure Index for Hong Kong occupations. The Labour and Welfare Bureau and the Census and Statistics Department should map Hong Kong’s occupations against international measures of AI exposure, publish the results, and include them in every future Manpower Projection. Occupations in the top quarter of exposure would count as high-exposure occupations for the measures below.
2. A “Retrain Before Redundancy” allowance. Employed workers in high-exposure occupations who earn below the median monthly wage would get the ERB’s existing half-day rate of HK$166.50 per session for evening and weekend upskilling, up to 60 sessions (HK$9,990) in any 12 months. This extends an allowance that already exists to people who are still in work, rather than creating a new scheme.
3. Pay course fees upfront for at-risk workers. For the same group, the Continuing Education Fund should pay approved course fees straight to the training provider instead of reimbursing the worker afterwards.
4. Career Switch Pathways into shortage sectors. The ERB should design placement-tied courses with employers in the shortage industries named in the Manpower Projection, such as elderly care, healthcare support, building and city operations, and construction. Employers taking part would commit to interviewing every graduate of the course. Trainees would receive the existing retraining allowance of up to HK$8,000 a month.
5. A “Train-to-Keep” incentive for employers. Firms that use government technology subsidies, such as the Technology Voucher Programme, to automate work with AI could claim a top-up of up to HK$20,000 per worker they retrain into a new role instead of dismissing. That turns AI adoption from a reason to cut staff into a reason to redeploy them.
Cost
| Item | Basis | Up to (HK$, 3 years) |
|---|---|---|
| Retrain Before Redundancy allowance | 20,000 workers × HK$9,990 | 200 million |
| Train-to-Keep top-up | 2,000 workers × HK$20,000 | 40 million |
| AI Exposure Index | Within existing LWB and C&SD resources | — |
| Upfront CEF payment | A change in payment timing, not new spending | — |
| Total | ≈ 240 million |
Career Switch Pathways use the ERB’s existing course and allowance budgets. Since not every eligible worker will claim all 60 sessions, actual spending would likely be well below the ceiling.
Funding source: the Employees Retraining Fund, which is paid for by the Employees Retraining Levy that employers pay when importing workers. As labour importation grows to fill shortages, it’s fair for that levy to fund retraining for local workers whose jobs are changing.
The case for
- Prevention is cheaper than cure. Paying a worker HK$9,990 to retrain while employed costs far less than months of unemployment, lost tax revenue and welfare support after they’ve been let go.
- It matches supply to demand. Steering displaced workers into shortage sectors tackles both problems at once and reduces how many workers need to be imported.
- It builds on what exists. Every measure extends something already in place: the ERB allowance, the Continuing Education Fund, the Technology Voucher Programme and the Manpower Projection. That keeps the admin light.
- It shares the cost fairly. Employers who gain from AI and imported labour help pay for local workers to adjust.
The case against
- The forecasts may be wrong. Nobody knows exactly which jobs AI will replace. An exposure index might flag the wrong occupations and train the wrong people.
- Some of it pays for training that would have happened anyway. Some workers would have retrained regardless.
- Labels can backfire. Calling an occupation “high-exposure” could unsettle workers, weaken their bargaining power, or make employers less willing to hire into those roles.
- Not every switch is realistic. A middle-aged office worker may not want to move into elderly care or construction, and the pay may be lower. Training can’t fully fix a mismatch in preferences and wages.
- It may slow AI adoption. Any condition on technology subsidies, however light, adds friction for firms.
Our recommendation
On balance, we recommend all five measures, starting with the AI Exposure Index, since the others depend on it. The strongest objection is that forecasts are uncertain, so the index should be reviewed every year and the high-exposure list updated as the evidence changes. The Train-to-Keep incentive is deliberately a reward rather than a requirement, so it encourages firms to redeploy staff without penalising them for adopting AI.
How we’d measure it
- Targeting. The share of allowance recipients who come from high-exposure occupations.
- Outcomes. Participants’ employment and earnings 12 months after training, compared with similar workers who didn’t take part.
- Mismatch. A quarterly figure from the Census and Statistics Department on job vacancies per unemployed person, by occupation group. A widening gap between groups is the early warning sign of structural unemployment.
- Time out of work. The share of unemployed former clerical workers who have been out of work for more than six months.
What’s happened since
- The 2026–27 Budget (February 2026) announced that the ERB will be upgraded as Upskill Hong Kong, offering skills-based courses including AI applications.
- Hong Kong’s seasonally adjusted unemployment rate rose to 3.8% in December 2025 to February 2026, up from 3.2% a year earlier.
- In September 2026, the Labour and Welfare Bureau’s Mid-term Update of Manpower Projection projected that, as companies use more AI for routine admin, clerical support workers will see a surplus of about 25,000 to 30,000 by 2028, while the overall shortage narrows to around 130,000.
References
- Census and Statistics Department, unemployment and underemployment statistics for December 2024 – February 2025, 18 March 2025
- China Daily HK, “Report: HK may face huge manpower shortage by 2028”, 14 November 2024
- The Chief Executive’s 2024 Policy Address, paragraph 208
- Employees Retraining Board, skills-based training strategy from 1 January 2025
- Employees Retraining Board, maximum monthly retraining allowance raised to HK$8,000
- Legislative Council Question 20, “Development of artificial intelligence”, 19 March 2025
- IMF, “AI Will Transform the Global Economy. Let’s Make Sure It Benefits Humanity”, January 2024
- ERB, on the 2026–27 Budget’s plan to upgrade the ERB as Upskill Hong Kong
- news.gov.hk, March 2026
- Bastille Post, on the Mid-term Update of Manpower Projection